Stock Picking Performance of Fast Money Experts
Steve LeCompte | March 12, 2009 | Posted in: Individual Gurus
As suggested by a reader, this entry examines the stock picking performance of experts featured on CNBC’s Fast Money. According to CNBC, these experts “give you the information normally reserved for the Wall Street trading floor, enabling you to make decisions that can make you money.” Do their stock picks actually make money fast? Do they outperform the broad stock market? Using stock picks recorded in entries entitled “Your First Move for Monday” (or Tuesday when Monday is a holiday) in the Fast Money Rapid Recap archive and weekly price data for those picks over the period 8/10/07 through 2/27/09, we find that:
This sampling method yields 212 picks encompassing 141 distinct stocks and funds. We analyze returns for these picks using the following assumptions:
- Each recommendation executes at the open on the designated Monday (or Tuesday when Monday is a holiday). The return for the first week is therefore from Monday open to Friday close. The returns for holding the position for the next 12 weeks are from Friday close to Friday close. We stop tracking returns after a 13-week horizon because they are not “fast money.” We also stop tracking returns when a pick is acquired and no longer traded.
- When the experts pick a stock more than once, we include its returns multiple times.
- Weekly stock prices are from Yahoo!Finance, except for Hilton Hotels (HLT). Trading in HLT ceased in October 2007. Weekly prices for HLT are from an historical chart at MSN Money, covering only a 10-week holding period from the recommended buy date.
- To adjust for market returns, we subtract contemporaneous weekly returns for SPY.
- Averages weight each stock pick equally.
- Return calculations ignore the impacts of transaction costs/trading frictions, dividends and capital requirements (except for an anomalous $51 dividend paid by MO, which we include).
The following chart compares the average cumulative performance of all expert picks in the sample to that of the overall market (SPY) for periods ranging from one week to 13 weeks after pick. Sample size generally declines with length of investment horizon (recent picks have not been held a full 13 weeks), from 212 picks for Week 1 to 174 picks for Week 13. As the sample has grown, the aggregate performance of the experts (before trading frictions) has generally become more like that of SPY. Note that:
The Fast Money experts have on average offered no “fast money.” Average raw cumulative returns for expert picks (black line) are negative for all weeks over the 13-week test horizon (before trading frictions).
The experts as a group perform very similarly to contemporaneous investments in SPY (green line) on a cumulative return basis over nearly all of the 13-week test horizon.
How have the long-only picks of the experts performed?
The next chart depicts the average raw cumulative returns for the 188 long and 24 short picks of the Fast Money experts. The short picks include six recommendations to buy inverse funds. The long positions by themselves have underperformed SPY over most of the 13-week test period and indicate no stock picking ability. The short positions alone generate positive cumulative returns for most of the 13 weeks in the test period. Declines in the broad stock market over parts of the test period tend to aid the performance of short positions. However, as seen in the previous graph, the short recommendations do not make the experts outperform the overall stock market.
Can we compare the stock picking abilities of individual Fast Money experts?
The final chart shows the average raw cumulative returns over a 13-week horizon for five individual Fast Money experts: Guy Adami, Karen Finerman, Jeff Macke, Pete Najarian, Tim Seymour and Others. Results suggest that there could be differences in stock picking abilities. However, subsamples for individuals are small (24-44 for Week 1), and the variabilities of returns across stock picks are very large. Just a couple very good or very bad additional picks could therefore alter relative performance noticeably.
None of the experts have generated attractive raw returns.
In summary, the Fast Money experts as a group probably do not offer fast money with their stock picks, and their stock-picking ability as a group is unimpressive.
Note that SPY is value-weighted, while the expert results are equally-weighted across picks. Some equally-weighted portfolio may be more appropriate than SPY as a benchmark for the performance of the experts.
See Guru Grades for a snapshot of the accuracy of various experts in predicting the direction of the U.S. stock market, including links to evaluations of their individual commentaries. See also Blog Synthesis: The Wisdom of Analysts, Experts and Gurus for more general research on the performance of expert investors.
Become a CXO Member
Gain access to hundreds of premium investing research articles and CXO’s trading strategiesStock Picking Performance of Fast Money Experts Steve LeCompte | March 12, 2009 | Posted in: Individual Gurus As suggested by a reader, this entry examines the stock picking performance of
‘Fast Money Halftime Report’ Picks For August 18: Workhorse, Uber And More
On CNBC’s “Fast Money Halftime Report,” Jon Najarian said he’s a buyer of Workhorse Group Inc (NASDAQ: WKHS). He noticed unusual options activity in the name.
Bryn Talkington recommended a long position in Energy Transfer LP Unit (NYSE: ET). She said it has a distribution yield of close to 18% and you can also get a potential capital appreciation.
Sarat Sethi wants to buy Uber Technologies Inc (NYSE: UBER) on the news it launched Uber Pass subscription service.
Jon Najarian is a buyer of Workhorse Group Inc (NASDAQ: WKHS). He noticed unusual options activity in the name.
Josh Brown revealed he doubled his position in Store Capital Corp (NYSE: STOR) during the second quarter.
Stephanie Link likes Deere & Company (NYSE: DE).
See more from Benzinga
© 2020 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.
Airbus sells six jets rejected by AirAsia, denting surplus: sources
US STOCKS-Wall Street rises, Nasdaq hits record high on recovery hopes
Bitcoin Extends Decline After Biggest Slump Since Pandemic Hit
This week in Trumponomics: Grasping at stocks
NYC Cases Swell; U.K.’s Infection Rate Tumbles: Virus Update
EV battery developer QuantumScape begins trading on NYSE
QuantumScape, a battery developer for electric vehicle use, began trading on the New York Stock Exchange today following a SPAC merger.
2 Stocks Flirting With a Bottom; Analysts Say ‘Buy’
When a stock starts dropping, investors have to ask two questions. First, why it’s dropping? Is something wrong with it? Or is it just facing a storm of circumstance, but is otherwise sound? If the latter, then the second question comes into play. Has this stock hit bottom?When a sound stock hits bottom, that’s a signal for investors to buy in. You can’t go wrong buying low and selling high, but you do have to know when ‘low’ is happening – otherwise you can miss your chance to maximize the profits.Wall Street’s analysts make their reputation by calling stocks right. Lately, some of these analysts have been tapping several apparent down-and-out equities as prime candidates for strong gains. These are stocks that, based on the TipRanks data, fit a profile: each has fallen on hard times during 2020; each has an average upside that starts north of 40%, and each has at least one analyst saying it’s likely to make radical gains in 2021.Benefitfocus (BNFT)We’ll start in the world of benefits management, an important sector that impacts a number of fields. Employers, insurance brokers, health plans, and retail partnerships all offer benefits to consumers of various stripes – and Benefitfocus offers a tech solution to make benefit administration easy. The company offers a software platform specifically designed to handle the HR and data aspects of benefits programs, from enrollment to management.This niche can be a two-edged sword, however. In good times, with benefit programs swinging, everyone will want in – but in bad times, Benefitfocus has found itself unable to regain traction. The company’s stock is down 42% year-to-date, and the third quarter results showed continuing year-over-year losses. Revenue is down 11% yoy, to $63.6 million, with declines across all of the company’s main segments: software revenue, subscription revenue, and platform revenue.At the same time, there were positive developments. Lincoln Financial Group and PayActive joined Benefitfocus as catalog suppliers, and the company held its first open enrollment with the University of Texas system. The company also ended Q3 with $176 million in cash on hand.These quarterly results came as Benefitfocus brought in new management. The company announced Stephen Swad as the new CEO, with his CFO position being filled by Alpana Wegner. In addition, the company announced new hires for the Chief Data Officer and EVP, Product & Engineering positions. These are major moves, that portend a new outlook at the top.Covering this stock for Piper Sandler, 5-star analyst Sean Wieland writes of BNFT: “With new mgmt at the helm, we sense a renewed energy moving the business forward. SaaS offerings are an area of focus, going head first into the B2B2C channel while de-emphasizing the direct to consumer business. Health of this customer base continues to trend above expectations, with a positive benefit fromgig workers, increasing net eligible lives 8.3% y/y to 18.2M. OEP fits into this positive narrative, as mgmt is happy with progress thus far, seeing continued strength as the selling season progresses.”Wieland’s bullish outlook is also supported by his Overweight (i.e. Buy) rating and $29 price target, which implies a 132% one-year upside. (To watch Wieland’s track record, click here)Overall, Wall Street appears to be in agreement with Wieland on BNFT. The stock has a Strong Buy consensus rating, based on 3 Buy reviews and 1 Hold. Shares are selling for $12.50 and the average price target, at $17.67, suggests room for a 41% upside in the next 12 months. (See BNFT stock analysis on TipRanks)Momo, Inc. (MOMO)Next up is Momo, the Chinese social media mobile app. This company offers customers a free smartphone app for social posting and instant messaging, and monetizes the service through the usual routs of third-party services and paid subscriptions for upgrades.Momo has badly underperformed this year, however, having lost 54% year-to-date. The company’s fiscal third-quarter came in below expectation, with earnings at 30 cents per share and revenues at $3.9 billion. These numbers were down significantly year-over-year, especially the EPS, which showed a 40% yoy drop. Revenue and earnings peaked in 4Q19, as the corona virus started to break out – and its has yet to recover.Like BNFT above, Momo has had management changes in the calendar third quarter. The company brought on board a new Executive Chairman as well as a new CEO. It is hoped that the new blood will bring new energy at the top. The new CEO, Li Wang, previously served as company COO since 2014.Leo Chiang, of Deutsche Bank, acknowledges that Momo is in a tight spot, but believes the company can chart a course out. “Momo app is navigating to focusing on content ecosystem, user engagement and community activity to revitalize middle and long tail users, instead of exploiting top paying cohort, whose spending sentiment has been impaired significantly post pandemic. The process has begun in early August and management expects it to last for 6 months. We believe it could lead to a healthier long-term prosperity for a social app,” Chiang noted.Chiang sets a $25 price target here, indicating a possible 68% upside potential, to go along with his Buy rating. (To watch Chiang’s track record, click here)The analyst consensus here is a Moderate Buy, based on 8 reviews that include 3 Buys and 5 Holds. The stock’s average price target of $21.49 suggests a 45% upside from the current share price of $14.83. (See MOMO stock analysis on TipRanks)To find good ideas for beaten-down stocks trading at attractive valuations, visit TipRanks’ Best Stocks to Buy, a newly launched tool that unites all of TipRanks’ equity insights.Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the featured analysts. The content is intended to be used for informational purposes only. It is very important to do your own analysis before making any investment.
What’s the Difference Between Retirement in Canada and America?
American and Canadian governments provide many of the same types of services for those in retirement, but the subtle differences between the two countries are worth noting.
Comcast is hiking TV and internet prices in 2021
You’ll have to pay more for Comcast’s services starting next year. The company will raise its prices for both cable TV and internet, and according to a price list posted on Reddit, they’ll be effective as soon as January 1st, 2021. According to the poster, the new prices are for the Chicago area, but Ars Technica has confirmed that price hikes are coming to all customers across the US.
7 Outdated Tech Stocks to Sell Before It’s Too Late
Tech stocks have the potential to deliver spectacular returns. Even older companies that fall to the wayside can release a new product that turns out to be a game changer. Investors won’t easily forget about about the once-struggling PC maker that went on to release the iPod and iPhone — becoming America’s first $2 trillion public company. However, for every Yin there is a Yang. Actually, there are many — tech companies that may have held promise, but now seem destined to fade. Failure or mediocrity is far more common than explosive growth. 10 Best Stocks to Buy for Investors Under 30 Here are 7 tech stocks that are fast approaching their sell-by date:InvestorPlace – Stock Market News, Stock Advice & Trading Tips Cars.com (NYSE:CARS) Fangdd Network Group (NASDAQ:DUO) National Instruments (NASDAQ:NATI) New Relic (NYSE:NEWR) Sabre (NYSE:SABR) WEX (NYSE:WEX) Yiren Digital (NYSE:YRD) If any of these equities are currently in your portfolio, it may be time to think about selling. Outdated Tech Stocks To Sell: Cars.com (CARS) Source: Shutterstock There was a time when Cars.com seemed like the future of buying cars. Why go into a dealership and haggle with the sales department when you could buy a car online? And for a short time, investors were convinced this was one of the next big tech stocks. In two short years, CARS stock grew at a rapid pace, racking up 455% of gains between 2015 and 2017. After closing at a record high $50.53 in October 2017, it’s been all downhill ever since. It turns out that not everyone is ready to buy their car on the internet. And Cars.com faced growing competition besides. The number of car dealers signed up for its service began to drop, as did advertising and revenue. In 2019, when a potential sale of the company fell through, CARS stock plummeted 34% in one day, dropping its market capitalization from $1.2 billion to $786 million. Those who held onto their shares are wishing they had dumped them then. With the pandemic further cutting into its business, Cars.com stock is now trading in the $3.60 level with a market capitalization of just over $318 million. Fangdd Network Group (DUO) Source: Shutterstock A lot of people have bought into Chinese tech stocks, which makes sense given the size of the market they serve. As China ramps up adoption of various technologies, many of these companies seem poised to take off in value. A good example of this thought process is Fangdd Network Group, which operates an online real estate marketplace. Given the rising rate of home ownership in China, plus the growing rate of internet access (over 900 million people in that country are now on the web), DUO stock would seem like a win. But things haven’t turned out that way. A short gain after its November 2019 initial public offering has been followed by an extended slide. In its latest quarter, revenue not only missed estimates, it declined 9% year-over-year, while earnings per share were down 43% YoY. And you can’t really blame the pandemic, because China recovered early from the coronavirus and its real estate market quickly rebounded. 10 Best Stocks to Buy for Investors Under 30 DUO stock now trades at $7.36, and shares are worth less than half what they were at the start of the year. Add in the growing risk of holding Chinese stocks due tightening U.S. stock market regulations, and this “F” rated stock simply isn’t worth the risk of holding onto. National Instruments (NATI) Founded in 1976, National Instruments specializes in measurement, automation, and engineering software, along with complementary hardware. The company’s flagship product is its LabVIEW system-design platform. The company’s annual revenue peaked at $1.359 billion in 2018. Not coincidentally, 2018 also marked the all-time highest close for NATI stock. It hit $52.81 in March of that year. Since then, it’s been downhill for NATI. It did bounce back from the stock market crash in March, but has yet to recover to January levels. With NATI stock down 30% from its 2018 high and an “F” rating in Portfolio Grader, I’d say now is the time to consider dumping this stock before it falls further. New Relic (NEWR) Source: Shutterstock San Fransisco-based New Relic offers SaaS systems for real-time monitoring of the performance of web and mobile applications. Shares in the company saw rapid growth through 2017 and 2018, but the stock has struggled since. In August, it was revealed that New Relic customers are not signing up for additional services. They aren’t expanding their use of the company’s products, which isn’t a great sign; existing customers that upgrade are much cheaper to obtain than net new clients. New Relic is trying to counter this with a revamp of its New Relic One platform. However, market reaction to that move — which risks customers leaving rather than transition to a new platform — was not good. NEWR stock was slammed, and JPMorgan analyst Sterling Auty downgraded the stock, citing concerns about the company’s “radical change” strategy. In its most recent quarter, New Relic whiffed badly on earnings. A year ago, the company delivered earnings per share of 24 cents. Analysts were expecting just two cents per share this year, but the company reported a loss of seven cents per share. That triggered another big loss, this time seeing NEWR stock drop 15% on the day. 10 Best Stocks to Buy for Investors Under 30 Time to think about cutting your losses on this “D-rated” tech stock. Sabre (SABR) Source: IgorGolovniov / Shutterstock.com If you were to look at the performance of SABR stock over the past six months, you might be impressed. A gain of nearly 32% since the end of May — not too bad at all. However, with Sabre you have to look at the bigger picture. And nothing about that bigger picture is pretty. Sabre is known for software and SaaS solutions for the travel industry. The company got its start by creating the world’s first computerized airline reservation system. Sabre describes itself as the “global technology provider to the travel industry.” Few tech stocks could be in a worse position today than those that rely on the travel industry as customers. From cruise lines, to hotel chains, to airlines, the travel sector has been devastated by the coronavirus pandemic. And even with vaccines on the horizon, any prospect of a real recovery may well be years away. Reflecting this grim reality, SABR stock remains down 54% from January levels. Given that the stock’s all-time high was five years ago, it seemed to be running out of steam even before the pandemic hit. SABR earns a “D” rating in Portfolio Grader, and its best years are definitely behind it. WEX Source: PREMIO STOCK / Shutterstock.com Not all investment analysts would agree with my decision to include WEX in this list. Among the 20 surveyed by the Wall Street Journal, 11 have it rated as a hold. Even with eight analysts giving WEX stock a “Buy” rating, plus one rating it as “Overweight,” the average 12-month price target of $163 has 10% downside. Why the mixed message on WEX? This is a payment processing and IT company that operates primarily within the fleet fuel cards, health benefits, and travel sectors. All three of these have come under heavy pressure in 2020. Lower fuel prices and reduced travel cut into its fleet revenue, travel has been hammered by the pandemic and coronavirus crowding at hospitals has had an impact on health division revenue as surgeries and elective procedures are cancelled. After 15 years of solid growth, WEX stock has taken a big hit in 2020, down 28% from its February highs. There’s a possibility that WEX bounces back in the post-pandemic world. But with the lasting ripple effects of the pandemic, any recovery will take time. 10 Best Stocks to Buy for Investors Under 30 At just over $181, WEX is currently trading at 2018 levels. Unless you bought it after that (in which case you may well decide to be patient, ride it out and hope for the best), I would be inclined to sell and move onto a tech stock with a more promising trajectory. Yiren Digital (YDR) Source: Shutterstock Like Fangdd Netw ork Group, Yiren Digital is another Chinese online marketplace that seems like a perfect growth investment — on the surface. While Fangdd is focused on real estate, Yiren Digital bills itself as a consumer finance marketplace, connecting borrowers and lenders. The promise of 1.4 billion people in one of the world’s fastest growing economies looking for financing? That was a story that pushed YDR stock to rapid growth when it went public in the U.S. at the close of 2015. Yiren Digital shares grew 432% in value in under two years. Then reality caught up. The borrowers that Yiren Digital was marketing to are largely classified as subprime. They were borrowing online because traditional banks wouldn’t touch them. And the Chinese government began to crack down on online lending. TDR stock began a steep decline in 2017. By the start of 2020 it had dropped 88%. The misery for investors has continued this year, with further loses of 45% so far in 2020. If you own this tech stock, now is time to cut it loose before it’s worthless. Louis Navellier had an unconventional start, as a grad student who accidentally built a market-beating stock system —with returns rivaling even Warren Buffett. In his latest feat, Louis discovered the “Master Key” to profiting from the biggest tech revolution of this (or any) generation. On the date of publication, neither Louis Navellier nor the InvestorPlace Research Staff member primarily responsible for this article held (either directly or indirectly) any positions in the securities mentioned in this article. More From InvestorPlace Why Everyone Is Investing in 5G All WRONG Top Stock Picker Reveals His Next 1,000% Winner Radical New Battery Could Dismantle Oil Markets The post 7 Outdated Tech Stocks to Sell Before It’s Too Late appeared first on InvestorPlace.
Is Apple Stock A Buy Right Now? Here’s What Its Stock Chart Shows
Apple has been an American success story several times over with the Mac, iPod, iPhone and other inventions. But is Apple stock a buy now? Here’s what its stock chart and earnings show.
3 Stocks for Investors Chasing High Paying Dividends
Looking for an alternative to low-interest savings accounts or bonds? Check out these S&P; 500 stocks that pay an annual dividend yield of over 7%.On CNBC's "Fast Money Halftime Report," Jon Najarian said he's a buyer of Workhorse Group Inc (NASDAQ: WKHS). He noticed unusual options activity in the name.Bryn Talkington recommended a long position in Energy Transfer LP Unit (NYSE: ET). She said it has a distribution yield of close to 18% and you can also get a potential capital appreciation.Sarat Sethi wants to buy Uber Technologies Inc (NYSE: UBER) on the news it launched Uber Pass subscription service.Jon Najarian is a buyer of Workhorse Group Inc (NASDAQ: WKHS). He noticed unusual options activity in the name.Josh Brown revealed he doubled his position in Store Capital Corp (NYSE: STOR) during the second quarter.Stephanie Link likes Deere & Company (NYSE: DE).See more from Benzinga * Mike Khouw Sees Unusual Options Activity In Occidental Petroleum * Cramer Weighs In On Ping Identity, Vertex And More * 2 Ways To Trade Apple's Stock Right Now(C) 2020 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved. ]]>